OOP stands for Object-Oriented Programming. What does it mean? And what’s the difference between OOP and procedural programming? We’ll go through all these terms, We’ll demonstrate the difference of these approaches and advantages of the OOP over procedural concept. Examples are for PHP, but concept is the same in all object-oriented languages.

So, let’s start with defining, what OOP is and how it differs from procedural programming. Just take a look around. For example, you see a table. Consider you have to program it. When using procedural approach, you focus on it’s behaviour (for example, you write function, that calculates height or that assembles it from the given dimensions). However, table has properties besides behaviour. When following procedural paradigm, we create variables for each property – height, width, length, square, weight. All that data – properties (variables) and behaviour (functions) describe the object from the real world – table. What’s wrong with this approach? Nothing wrong, everything is fine, when we’re dealing with one table.

Procedural programming – the problem

And now imagine if we have several table types – square, triangle and rounded. Consider the following task. We have to calculate square of every table. Let’s try to do this with procedural approach, without any objects. Each table has only one property, that we’re interested in – side for triangle and square and radius for rounded one. Now we’ll create 3 functions, that calculate the square. (see formulas for equilateral triangle and circle)

Everything is fine until we have to print list of tables with squares like:

To process it, we need one more parameter in our array – the type of the table. And adding it makes array a 2-dimensional one:

And now let’s program processing of these arrays (using the trick with for loop):

Yes! We did it – created all the stuff we had to and it works fine. But take a look at this. In the array we have to specify the table type, then check it and select the corresponding function. And how about dealing with 10 table types? Adding each type requires adding new calculation function and changing the printing one.

OOP – solution

And now we’ll take a look at the object-oriented solution. Maybe you’ve heard of the 3 principles of the OO programming – Inheritance, Encapsulation, Polymorphism. And all of them are used even in this simple example. But before plunging into the OO world, let’s see, what is object.
When developing, by saying “object” we mean some abstraction of the real world object (not always real, it may be an abstraction), that has some attributes (called properties or fields) and behaviour or actions (called methods).
So since object holds both it’s properties and behaviour, we can define 3 classes and use them all. Yes, we mentioned “classes”. Classes are “blueprints” for objects. Class describes, what properties the object will have, what methods will work with his properties and how. And when we need the object of this class to work with, we instantiate it.

Basically, you can imagine class as an empty pot. It has properties:

• contents
• volume

And objects of that class are:

• Big pot with honey (Contents = “honey”, volume=”big”)
• Little pot with water (Contents = “water”, volume=”little”)
• Medium-sized empty pot (Contents = “”, volume=”medium”)

You also can imagine the process of instantiation of the pot as the sequence of operations:

1. Take blueprint (class definition)
2. Create pot from clay (allocate memory according to the class definition)
3. Put something into the pot (Initialize properties with some values)

Steps #1 and #2 are done automatically by the programming language compiler (or interpreter), and the third step depends on the:

• Class definition – you can specify default values for the properties
• Class constructor – you can define special function, that takes care of attributes initialization. We’ll talk aabout them later.

So, now we have theory, let’s start coding.

In PHP, when we define the property without specifying it’s visibility, it is considered public. That means, that we can create an object and access it’s public property:

Other variants are private and protected. When we define property as private, it can be accessed only from methods of the same class. This is used for some internal variables. Protected is the same as private, but it can be accessed from the child classes also. Don’t worry if you don’t understand the concept now, we’ll go through this later.
Note: In other languages default visibility may be different! (e.g. C++ properties are defined as private by default)

Refactoring OO solution

Code refactoring is the process of changing a computer program’s internal structure without modifying its external functional behaviour or existing functionality. This is usually done to improve external or internal non-functional properties of the software, such as code readability, simplify code structure, change code to adhere to a given programming paradigm, improve maintainability, improve extensibility, or increase execution performance. (Wikipedia)

Now let’s take a close look at these classes. All of them have one parameter and a common method getSquare(). We can create the parent object – Table and extend these three classes from it. See the UML diagram:

This should be evident, but we’ll explain what’s there. First of all, we have class Table. It is a parent class for all tables. Then we have three derived classes (arrow points from child to the parent class), which override parent’s getSquare() method.
and the code:

Make it work!

So, everything is OK now and we can print the same table using defined classes. Unlike previous approach, we’ll have a simple array of objects here:

Note, that we don’t need any function selection, we just call getSquare() for any object. And since all of them have it (that’s why we defined common parent for them), we get correct result depending on the object we’re working with.
One more benefit is extending this code. Remember, when using procedural approach, to add new table type we had to add new function and modify the printing function. Using object-oriented approach, all we have to do is to create one more class. The printing function (which may contain complex logic or be hidden from the end-user) remains unchanged. So with OOP we write less and, at the same time, get much better solutions.

OOP principles explained

This principle, when different actions are performed when calling the same method for different objects, is called Polymorphism. Inheritance is the simplest thing for understanding – we used this to inherit (programmers usually say “extend”) three table classes from the one generic table class.

Finally, encapsulation is about hiding implementation details from the end-used. Let’s take our example; imagine that there are 2 persons. One of them is excellent mathematician and he created that 4 classed (base class – Table and 3 derived (child) classes). Other should show that list. With procedural approach he should take a look at the procedures and write code, that determines the object type and calls correct function. With OOA (object-oriented approach) he doesn’t have to know that. He just calls getSquare() and doesn’t care about anything.

Further improvements

To make these principles more understandable, let’s improve our code and add some data to the objects. Let’s store height of the table and then print volume, that it occupies. Volume=Square*Height. Square is calculated differently, formula for volume is the same. So we add new property to the parent class – $height. And new method – getVolume(). Note, we don’t change any child class at all!

And here is how it works:

Note, that we didn’t define $height or method getVolume() in CircleTable class, this is inherited from parent class. Don’t you think it’s very convenient?

By the way, we used design pattern here, which is called TemplateMethod – we defined method getVolume(), which uses method getSquare(). And getSquare() itself is defined in the derived classes. Read more about this pattern in my future posts

Using constructors

Now let’s do some more improvements – we’ll create constructors for the classes. Constructor is special function, that is called when object is created. We’ve already mentioned them. In PHP 5 constructor is defined as a special function, named __construct. It is a regular method, but it can’t return any value. However, it can be public, private or protected. Usually, constructors are private unless some design pattern is used (e.g. Singleton). Here is the code, that uses constructors for smarter object initialization:

Here is how to create such classes:

The following usage is the same, it just helps to initialize object attributes in one line of code, encapsulating some preprocessing. For example, we know that height can’t be negative, so we can correct definition of the Table class:

So you can see, using constructors is VERY handy.
Note, if you have the properties public (like in this example), you may still use $table->radius to access it.

Attributes and methods access

Finally, let’s take a look at the properties and methods visibility. As we already mentioned, there are three access levels:

1. Public – accessible both from class itself ($this->property) and from outside ($user->login)
2. Protected – accessible from the class itself and from it’s derived classes ($this->property, property may be defined in current class or in the parent one)
3. Private – accessible only from the class itself ($this->property, property should be defined in the current class)

To demonstrate this in action, we’ll modify the Table class and make it’s $height property private. Since it is used only in getVolume() method, which is also defined in the Table class, it should work fine. Also, we add a new method setHeight(). This will be used to modify height since we’ll not have access to it through $table->height. So here is UML and the code:

Note, that we changed constructor, not it doesn’t set the height itself, it delegates this to the special setter function, which perform all validation. This is a good practice – to have attributes of an object hidden and have getter/setter methods to access it. Why? Because this way you control, what is returned and what is set and can ensure that object’s properties are always correct.
When using this definition, we’ll not be able to access $height in CircleTable or TriangleTable. To enable this, we can either add getter method or make $height protected. First variant will allow everybody to get the height. Second variant allows to get the $height only within the derived classes (see protected access level above)

Glossary

• Class is a formal definition of some real object or it’s abstraction. It contains definition of it’s both properties and methods.
• Object is an instantiated class
• Property is a special variable, that represents some attribute of an object. Sometimes it is called “member variable”
• Method is a special function, that describes some behaviour of an object.
• Constructor is a special method, that is called when object is created. This is mainly used for the object initialization.
• Getter is a special method, that returns property value. Usually used for private or protected properties or for some kind of processing before returning.
• Setter is a special method, that sets property value. Used for private or protected variables or for some additional validation.
• Superclass is same as parent class or base class
• Subclass is same as derived class, child class, extended class
• Inheritance is an OOP principle, which is used to define some common behaviour in the base class and then extend it and use in the derived classes.
• Encapsulation is an OOP principle, which used for hiding implementation details from the end-user. (remember example with two programmers developing these table classes)
• Polymorphysm in an OOP principle, which allows different classes to behave differently when calling the same method.
• Design pattern is some standard proven solution to the common problem. For example, Singleton pattern solves the problem when we need some common resource in different places of an application. For example DB abstraction object.
• Refactoring is the process of changing the source code to make it work faster, look better, use better solutions, be better in support and future development

Further reading

• Creator and Information Expert GRASP principles
• OOP
• Procedural programming
• Constructor
• Design patterns: Singleton
• Design patterns: Template method
• Equilateral triangle
• Circle

Liked the post? Bookmark it

Hide Sites

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.